Right now, the top picks for ice cream in Sayulita are Athea, Sayu Swirls and Rollado Ice Cream, ranked by 21 head-to-head comparisons from locals and travelers.
No ads or paid placements: only people who have been there weigh in, by choosing between places they know. Each place shows how many comparisons it has, how many people have been there, and how settled its rank is.
Rankings
Athea — 8 comparisons · 1 person has been here · medium confidence. Known for: Frozen Yogurt Map
Sayu Swirls — 4 comparisons · 1 person has been here · provisional (few comparisons) Map
Rollado Ice Cream — 8 comparisons · 2 people have been here · medium confidence Thai-style hand-rolled ice cream served in Mexican waffle taco cones from a pink truck. Map · @rolladoicecream
Gelatoos — 5 comparisons · 1 person has been here · provisional (few comparisons) Artisanal gelateria with vegan and sugar-free options. Map
Wakika — 7 comparisons · 2 people have been here · provisional (few comparisons). Known for: Waffle Cone, Fruit Flavors, Paletas, Chocolate Family-run heladeria since 1996 famous for 20+ popsicle flavors and fresh paletas. Map · @wakikasayulita
Mistery Ice Pops — 2 comparisons · 0 people have been here · provisional (few comparisons) Artisan paleta chain with 25+ creamy flavors, vegan options, and Italian-imported ingredients. Map · @misteryicepops
Buonissimo — 4 comparisons · 0 people have been here · provisional (few comparisons) Italian-style gelato shop with exotic flavors rivaling the real thing from Italy. Map · @gbcafe
La Fuente — 4 comparisons · 0 people have been here · provisional (few comparisons) Plaza-corner ice cream and paleta shop with fresh fruit pops and chocolate-dipped bananas. Map · @lafuentesayulita
Why these rankings can be trusted
Only people who have been there weigh in. You can only vote on a place you have actually visited, so every vote comes from first-hand experience.
Places are compared, not starred. People choose the better of two places they both know. A direct choice between real alternatives says more than a star rating given in isolation.
Rank is earned over many choices. A place rises by being chosen over strong alternatives again and again, by many different people. One enthusiastic fan, or one bad day, cannot decide a rank.
More comparisons, more certainty. Each place shows how many comparisons it has. Places with many have settled ranks; places with few are marked provisional, and a low provisional rank means little data, not a bad place.
Independent. No ads, no sponsored spots, and businesses cannot pay to be listed or ranked. Rankings change only when people who know the places weigh in.
FAQ
What is ranked #1 for ice cream & paletas in Sayulita?
Athea is #1, followed by Sayu Swirls and Rollado Ice Cream. The ranking comes from 21 head-to-head comparisons by people who have been there, and it updates as new votes come in.